OFFICIAL DEVELOPMENT PREVIEW
Skip to Holy Wars Wiki
Research dossier 118

Non-Political ↔ Traditional Values: Exclusionary Expression & Evidence Gaps

A traditional-family advocate’s public endorsement of exclusion toward Jehovah’s Witnesses, with actor roles independently established and five directions still open.

Source-checked adaptationUpdated October 27, 2026Version 1.0
Reality and fiction, clearly marked. Evidence sections describe the sources; game sections describe authored characters and events. Source-checked does not mean reviewed by a clinician or theologian. Read the evidence-status guide.
RESEARCH NOTES

01 Scope and evidence status

One dated exclusionary statement is retained. It is not a finding about all traditionalists, religious people or political abstainers. Five directions remain unestablished.

RESEARCH NOTES

02 Independent actor classification

Traditional Values concerns inherited social and family norms; religious affiliation or partisan conservatism alone does not establish it. Hilarion’s October 2015 address explicitly advocates traditional male–female marriage, childrearing and Church tradition, including cooperation on legal protection. This establishes the named actor’s advocacy rather than a category inferred from his office. [2]

The April 2016 Witness text prescribes abstention from elections, party alignment and government-change activity while permitting appeals for fair treatment and teaching law compliance. The target here is the institutional community, not an individual whose conduct is inferred from membership. [3]

REAL-WORLD · EVIDENCE

03 1. Non-Political → Traditional Values — Harmful interactions

Status: No suitable example established in the bounded research passes. This is an evidence gap, not historical absence or proof of exhaustive searching.

REAL-WORLD · EVIDENCE

04 2. Non-Political → Traditional Values — Ordinary / neutral coexistence

Status: No suitable example established in the bounded research passes. This is an evidence gap, not historical absence or proof of exhaustive searching.

REAL-WORLD · EVIDENCE

05 3. Non-Political → Traditional Values — Supportive interactions

Status: No suitable example established in the bounded research passes. This is an evidence gap, not historical absence or proof of exhaustive searching.

REAL-WORLD · EVIDENCE

06 4. Traditional Values → Non-Political — Exclusionary public expression

The DECR transcript of the April 29, 2017 broadcast records Metropolitan Hilarion welcoming the Witness ban and reduced access to meeting venues. He also denied Church participation or consultation and rejected criminal prosecution for religious dissent. [1]

This is retained under harmful interactions as public endorsement of exclusion, rather than theological disagreement alone. It does not show that Hilarion caused or implemented the state decision, or that political abstention motivated his statement. His allegations about families, health and extremism remain unverified source claims. [1]

REAL-WORLD · EVIDENCE

07 5. Traditional Values → Non-Political — Ordinary / neutral coexistence

Status: No suitable example established in the bounded research passes. This is an evidence gap, not historical absence or proof of exhaustive searching.

REAL-WORLD · EVIDENCE

08 6. Traditional Values → Non-Political — Supportive interactions

Status: No suitable example established in the bounded research passes. This is an evidence gap, not historical absence or proof of exhaustive searching.

RESEARCH NOTES

09 Qualifications and remaining work

This finding concerns public expression. Independent implementation, measured effects and the other five conduct directions require separate evidence. The broadcast transcript was inspected; the original recording was not independently reviewed.

The 2015 address establishes advocacy, not the truth of its descriptions of feminism, gender, other churches or public policy. Its theological and social claims are attributed positions. [2]

The Witness text establishes an institutional norm, not universal individual compliance or withdrawal from every civic activity. Political abstention and traditional social views can overlap without proving a separate interaction. [3]

Earlier Amish sources permit varying political participation; no blanket abstention classification is adopted. General praise of family life or shared heritage alone does not establish support for an abstaining counterpart. Earlier uninspected book leads remain open.

HOLY WARS · FICTION

10 What this means for Holy Wars

A documented statement belongs to a named actor in a specific context. It creates no collective guilt, automatic hostility, alliance, identity-based moral score or gameplay mechanic.

RESEARCH NOTES

11 Sources & further reading

  1. Митрополит Иларион: Мы не должны плевать в свою историю
    Russian Orthodox Church Department for External Church Relations · April 29, 2017 broadcast · opening Witness discussion and venue exchange
    Primary institutional Russian transcript; English paraphrases below, not an independently viewed recording
  2. Greetings to the Catholic Synod on the vocation and mission of the family
    Metropolitan Hilarion · DECR official English text · October 20, 2015 · concluding family/tradition and legislative-cooperation paragraphs
    Primary expression establishing traditional-family advocacy; not independent verification of polemical claims
  3. Maintain Your Neutrality in a Divided World
    The Watchtower—Study Edition / Jehovah’s Witnesses · April 2016 · pp.27–31 · paragraphs 1–3,6–7,9
    Primary institutional abstention teaching predating the statement, not individual behavior records
RESEARCH NOTES

12 Review and publication record

Prepared October 27, 2026 under William’s standing publication authorization. Section 4 only: retained exclusionary public expression; five categories remain unestablished. Full comparison incomplete / Needs review.

Canonical shared record and PUB-016 superseding source audit. Earlier cautions and research history preserved.

Follow the connection

Found In-Game

Explore each character or card, then follow its research tags back here.