OFFICIAL DEVELOPMENT PREVIEW
Skip to Holy Wars Wiki
Research dossier 137

Anger, Rumination and Diagnostic Restraint

What a laboratory anger study can explain—and why abusive behavior is not a diagnosis of bipolar disorder.

Source-checked adaptationUpdated November 16, 2026Version 1.0
Reality and fiction, clearly marked. Evidence sections describe the sources; game sections describe authored characters and events. Source-checked does not mean reviewed by a clinician or theologian. Read the evidence-status guide.
RESEARCH NOTES

01 Research question

Can repeated grievance be written credibly without treating violence as inevitable or assigning a psychiatric condition to Derek?

REAL-WORLD · EVIDENCE

02 Rumination is not reliable relief

Bushman’s experiment angered participants and compared punching a bag while thinking about the person who angered them, punching while thinking about fitness, and a no-bag control. The rumination condition produced greater reported anger and aggressive responding in the laboratory. The aggression measure involved noise blasts, not intimate-partner assault. [1]

RESEARCH NOTES

03 Keep the study in scope

This experiment challenges the idea that aggressive venting necessarily releases anger harmlessly. It does not establish Derek’s internal mechanism, predict a particular assault, or show that every angry person becomes violent. Responsibility for his behavior is not removed by an account of anger.

REAL-WORLD · EVIDENCE

04 Behavior is not a diagnosis

NIMH describes bipolar disorder through episodes involving mood, energy, activity and other symptoms, assessed in their broader course. Anger or controlling behavior alone is not sufficient evidence for that diagnosis. [2]

Editorial boundary: Derek is not assigned bipolar disorder, mania, psychosis or a substance-use history in this story. This dossier makes no categorical claim that psychiatric illness either always causes violence or can never be associated with it. Population-level risk questions cannot diagnose a fictional individual.

HOLY WARS · FICTION

05 Connection to The Sitting

Read or watch The Sitting, including all eight narrated parts. Derek returns to the same accusation, interrupts study and interprets events as grievances against him. The story depicts his choices and their consequences. The earlier gentle memory explains something about Sloan’s hope; it does not excuse later abuse.

RESEARCH NOTES

06 Sources and reading

Internal research threads: SLO-RES-08 and 09. Diagnostic restraint is a deliberate authorial boundary; no unverified prevalence figures are carried into this dossier.

  1. Does Venting Anger Feed or Extinguish the Flame? Catharsis, Rumination, Distraction, Anger, and Aggressive Responding
    Brad J. Bushman · 2002
    Original laboratory experiment; Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 28(6), 724–731; DOI 10.1177/0146167202289002
  2. Bipolar Disorder
    National Institute of Mental Health · Accessed November 16, 2026
    Clinical public information; diagnosis requires assessment of symptoms and course
RESEARCH NOTES

07 Publication record

Developed through the team’s research and review, with creative direction by William Byrd and contributions from Rowan, Claude, Jim, and Grace. Public source links and evidence limits were checked for this publication on November 16, 2026. Research grounds the fiction; it does not certify every event as medically or institutionally approved.

Follow the connection

Found In-Game

Explore each character or card, then follow its research tags back here.

The Sitting

The Sitting

Story · Eight narrated parts

Research behind the story, with sources and fictional choices distinguished.

Mira Sloane (Sloan)

Mira Sloane (Sloan)

Character

Background research connected to Sloan’s examination in The Sitting.